The naughty version of "Paper or Plastic?"

Conversation I had after my performance last night:

Leah: So, I had a question for you in anticipation of a future prank.
Me: Okay?
Leah: Satin or lace?
Me: ...uh...Satin?
Leah: Okay.
Me: It seems less naughty, somehow.
Leah: Oh, we can make it naughty.

I am terrified of what that means.